Okay, I know you are going to think that I AM a crunchy-granola kind of mom when I tell you that I started making my own dishwasher detergent. Well, I’m still not.
I know you are starting to doubt me, but follow my logic…
Store-bought soap is pricey, homemade soap is not. Homemade soap works better than store bought. Any questions? 😉
I found this recipe at DIY Natural. I already had most of the ingredients for dishwasher soap, because I had bought them when I made homemade laundry soap (and I already had the salt), so it really was a no brainer to switch over to homemade dishwasher soap.
Homemade Dishwasher Soap
1 cup Borax
1 cup washing soda
½ cup *kosher salt (*I used regular table salt, and it worked just fine.)
½ cup *citric acid (double this if you have hard water) (*I used 1 cup Lemishine found next to the rinse aids in the dishwasher-soap isle at Wal-Mart.) (You can also find citric acid in the canning isle, but I think you get more Lemishine for the money. JMO.) 😉
Mix everything together and store in a plastic container. Use 1 Tbsp per load. Use white vinegar in the rinse aid compartment of your dishwasher to help keep your dishes from getting spotty. If you buy the blue rinse aid stuff at the store look at spending $3.75 or more per 30 loads. If you use white vinegar, you’ll be spending about $0.06 per 30 loads. Hello! (When I use white vinegar in stuff other than for dying Easter eggs, I feel like Martha Stewart!)
I am very pleased with how well my dishes turn out. They look better than when I washed them with the store-bought stuff. (And I used the good expensive stuff!)
The glass on the left was washed with homemade soap and the glass on the right was washed with the good expensive store-bought stuff.
So, would you switch?
This recipe will clump. To reduce clumping, add a few tablespoons of rice in a cheese cloth and tie it up. The rice will pull out the moisture and keep the detergent from clumping.
Disclaimer: If you have hard water, you may have to adjust the amount of citric acid (or LemiShine) that you use, to keep your dishes from getting cloudy. Also, I’ve read that some people have had problems with the kosher salt being too abrasive on their dishes, because of the larger crystals. I use regular table salt and have had no problems. If you use table salt, you may want to get the kind without iodine, but that’s what I had, so that’s what I used. 😉
(This picture has nothing to do with dish soap, but I thought it was cute!)
I was going to tell you about how I made pre-measured soap biscuits. (or whatever you call them, I can’t think what they are called, so I’m going with soap biscuits. I think it has a certain ring to it, don’t you? Soap Biscuits…) Anyhoo, I was going to tell you how I made these little pre-measured biscuit thingys, but my experiment failed. And when I say “failed”, I mean, it FAILED. I will spare you with all the details, but lets just say it involved my oven and my food processor. Don’t ask!!!
So it’s back to square one for me. If anyone has any idea how to make soap biscuits, please let me know. Let me re-phrase that… If you have tried to make them and had success, let me know how you did it. 😉
*Update: I did figure this out. It took awhile, but here they are DIY Dishwasher Soap Packets. 😀
Favorite Sister 1 said:
Cool! Now I can try since I now know someone who has actually tried it! :o)
Martha said:
nifty, might have to try this! Thanks for sharing!
Pingback: DIY Dishwasher Soap Packets « Lady with the Red Rocker
Terri said:
Thanks, Stephanie. I tried DYI dishwasher detergent before and I didn’t like it. My dishes were cloudy, but I didn’t use LemiShine. Do you use 1 cup because you have hard water? We have hard water. Wondering if I need to use 1 cup or double it to 2 cups? Also, how much do you use if you don’t choose to make the soap packets? I’d rather just measure it out each time, and I will also try the rice in cheesecloth because yes, the other time I made it – it got hard and clumpy. Thanks again!
ladywiththeredrocker said:
Hey Terri! Miss you guys!
Yes, I have hard water so I use 1 cup of the LemiShine. If your water is really hard, you might go to a cup and a half. Also, I use vinegar as a rinse agent, instead of Jet Dry, and that also helps with the cloudiness. I think you kind of have to try the recipe a couple of times and adjust it to the hardness of your water. Hope this helps! Thanks for stopping by! 😀
PS. Yes, It is still just 1 Tablespoon per load.
thehouseofjuliet said:
Thanks for this recipe, I’ll definitely be trying it soon. Our dishwasher is two years old, and some of the dishes are not getting clean. I’ve been using gel cleaners, but maybe this will help. Found you randomly on Pinterest:) Julie
Kim @ Cheap Chic Home said:
I’ve never seen diy dishwasher soap. This intrigues me. I’m glad you even give a price comparison and a testimonial. Blessings, Kim
Terri said:
Hey Steph: Crunchy granola mom…. Read what you said….
“…store-bought soap is pricey, homemade soap is not. Homemade soap works better than store bought. Any questions?”
and I say this, “store-bought granola is pricey, homemade is not. Homemade granola is way healthier than store bought.” !! You will be a crunchy granola mom someday. You’re heading that way!! ha!!
Can’t wait to go to Walmart tomorrow and look for Lemishine. 🙂 Weird things excite us homemakers, huh?! Thanks!
ladywiththeredrocker said:
Hahaha! Funny woman! I do love homemade granola, just not too crunchy! Lol! 😀
That Girl said:
Where should I place the rice packet in the dishwasher? Do I put the rice and the DIY wash detergent together in the cloth or just the rice? Thanks!
ladywiththeredrocker said:
You place the rice in a cheese cloth by itself, and then store it in the same container that you put your dishwashing soap. The rice will draw out the moisture and keep the soap from becoming hard. Hope this helps! 😀
That Girl said:
Thanks!
Anne said:
thanks for sharing this….i just made my first batch of laundry detergent and was interested in making dish detergent as soon as my storebought stuff ran out, but our hard water was holding me back. now that i know what kind of adjustments to make (and the fact that other people who have hard water use the homemade stuff and it works for them!) i just might give it a go. thanks!!
Adrienne @ Whole New Mom said:
Hi there.
Did this really work better for you than the store bought? I tried it w/ citric acid and it was horrible. I went back to the tablets. I may have to try the Lemishine. I wonder if that will do it. There are a bunch of folks on the DIY Natural site who can’t get it to work. Frustrating- but I hope there’s still hope out there!
ladywiththeredrocker said:
Hi Adrienne! Yes, I do like my diy dish soap. I had to play around with the recipe a little to get it to work with the hardness of my water. You may have to use more LemiShine than I did if you are still having trouble with cloudiness. I also use vinegar as a rinse aid instead of Jet Dry, I think that helps keep the dishes from getting cloudy also. And I use regular table salt as opposed to the course salt, I read that the course salt could be too abrasive on the dishes. Hope this helps, and thanks for stopping by! 😀
Margaret said:
Stephanie, This is a really good recipe, and am thrilled that there are others out there who have the same frustrations with hard/lime water as I do, even with using fresh, smaller Cascade (old detergent, larger boxes lose their effectiveness). Lemi Shine is amazing, and wish they would make detergent, as well. I’ve tried vinegar, but it does nothing to stop spots, and actually made the lime more apparent. Peroxide, and baking soda, also work pretty well when I have run out of Lemi Shine. There is also the issue of if your drain is clogged, and dirty residue is backing up into the dishwasher. I’ve spent time cleaning the inside of the door around the gasket, as well. The truth is, the low-water dishwashers, coupled with low water pressure, do a terrible job, and especially if the water temperature is not at least 120 degrees, in order to dissolve the detergent. Your recipe is amazing, and you should be proud of your research, and it’s really home-based knowledge that helps us from over-paying for products that may not work.
ladywiththeredrocker said:
Thanks Margaret! I wish I could help you with your dishwasher problem… Is it time to get a new one yet??? 😀
Lauren said:
thank you for posting this! I am now starting to make my own detergents to save money and so happy I found your post for dish detergent! 🙂
Lauren
laurenphd.blogspot.com
concerned visitor said:
but be careful with the ingredients! specially advice children to do so. It takes a lot of time before borax leaves from our body. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borax#Toxicity
Kimberly said:
I’m excited to try this, thanks!
Marie said:
How much vinegar do you use as the rinse aid?
Thanks!
ladywiththeredrocker said:
Marie, I just put the vinegar in the little dispenser in the door of dishwasher where you would normally put Jet Dry, or any other brand of rinse aid. I fill it to the “full” line (maybe 1/2 cup? It’s hard to measure since I put it directly into the dishwasher). This usually lasts for about 30 loads.
Ashley said:
I really want to try this out. I have been making my own cleaners, laundry detergent, etc. This is the next step! 🙂 Thank you for sharing your recipe.
Jessica @ GurgleandCooBlog.com said:
Love this! Found it on a friend’s Pinterest…I’m trying this tomorrow! 🙂
Mandy said:
I’m excited to find this! We have impossibly hard water, so much so that even using the expensive stuff, our dishes were so cloudy! I finally called a repair company, convinced that something was wrong with our dishwasher. The scheduler was awesome (everyone is so friendly – that’s why we use that company), and totally walked me through some trouble shooting things to try. #1 – get LemiShine #2 – keep your rinse agent compartment filled. It was amazing the difference it made, so to find a recipe for homemade detergent with LemiShine already in it is awesome! Thanks!!!
Jen Price said:
Where can you buy the washing soda? I have never seen that before.
ladywiththeredrocker said:
Jen, I buy mine at Walmart in the laundry section. It is usually at the end of the isle next to the Borax. Hope this helps! Thanks for visiting! 😀
JoAnne said:
I made this this week and have used it three times. I love it! I made the little “biscuits” and they came out great. I have really hard water so I doubled the lemishine. As soon as my rinse agent runs out, I will switch to vinegar. I’m so tired of paying so much for “not so great” results. Thanks so much for posting this AND for linking up with “Sew Darn Crafty” where I saw it!
Kendra said:
Hi,
Love this detergent. This was my first DIY endeavor. It has been successful, except the detergent hardened which makes it hard to scoop out. Did you have this problem?
ladywiththeredrocker said:
Hi Kendra,
Yes, that is why I started making dishwasher soap packets, you can find the post here. But, if you would rather not make them, I did have success with keeping the soap from getting hard by storing it in a ziploc baggie.
I also, forgot to mention that you can put some rice (maybe a couple tablespoons worth) in a cheese cloth and tie it up into a little baggie and store it in with your detergent. Before I started making the packets, I was just keeping the detergent in a ziploc. Hope this helps! Thanks for stopping by! 😀
Terri said:
Oh, ziploc baggie – that’s a good idea. Mine is an old small coffee can and I noticed yesterday it is getting hard to scoop out – even with 2 cheesecloth balls of rice.
Do you do the rice in the baggie too? I guess I’m being lazy about making the packets, but maybe that is the best way afterall. I think I’ll try the ziploc baggie first!
Thanks, Stephanie!
ladywiththeredrocker said:
LOL! I forgot to mention about the cheese cloth with rice! No, I don’t use the cheese cloth and rice with the packets. Before I made the packets I was just keeping the detergent in a ziploc and that kept it from getting hard.
Anna Wilson said:
I was just wondering about the lemishine. My silverware is not supposed to be used with lemon cleaners.Is there an alternative to that??
ladywiththeredrocker said:
Anna, you can use citric acid in place of Lemishine, but I suspect that it’s the citric acid that you are not suppose to put on the silverware??
Stacey said:
I tried this recipe and it worked great except….for some reason the little detergent dispenser “door” on my dishwasher has a tendency to stick and with this all the soap did not come out and some of it was clumped together. We had to switch from liquid dish soap for this reason. WIth the commercial powders we don’t have the problem. It’s a newer dishwasher too. So…. any ideas what I can do with the rest of the detergent I made? Can it be used for sinks, bathtubs etc?
ladywiththeredrocker said:
Stacey,
When I first started using this detergent, i had the same problem. You may need to run an empty cycle with just LemiShine to get rid of any lime or soap build up. If you have any build up, it can keep the little dispenser from opening properly. Hope this helps! 😀
usmcwife92210 said:
I tried this tonight after finally running out of my commercial brand stuff and it works GREAT!!! im glad I finally have a new dishwasher soap!
Pingback: 18 Fantastic Uses for Washing Soda | PreparednessMama